How to make anchovies pizza – two ways. Plus a list of most compatible pizza toppings so you can fashion your own favorite version.
You are watching: What Goes Well With Anchovies On Pizza
- Go straight to the Recipe Card or
- Read on for useful tips and step by step pictures (2 mins).
Cured anchovies on pizza is an old secret when it comes to boosting flavor. But if you are an anchovies lover like me simply adding a couple to the pizza toppings or working them into the sauce is not enough.
Sometimes you just want to indulge and let them be the star ingredient. I have two favorite anchovy pizza recipes that do just that – one Croatian and one Italian inspired!
Quick Note on Anchovy Fillets
Anchovies are little marine forage fish often prepared as small fry. However, their culinary merits go far beyond the status of exceptional beer snacks.
In the Mediterranean tradition they are commonly cleaned, filleted, cured with salt and then packed in olive oil or water and canned.
Through the curing process the anchovy fillets get transformed into a potent, much coveted source of deep and not at all fishy flavor.
The fillets or anchovy paste made from them are frequently added to salad dressings, sauces (including for pasta), dips, spreads, tapenades, compound butters, marinades.
The exquisite flavor cured anchovies impart is a combination of rich umami taste coupled with briny saltiness.
They are very versatile and elevate numerous dishes where the contribution of umami is desired.
Anchovies Pizza Ideas
My first version is inspired by a thin crust pizza I once enjoyed on Rab island in Croatia and have been obsessed with ever since.
The second version is more of a classic pizza recipe, a la pizza Napoletana even though it does not comply with the strict rules for making its namesake.
By way of pizza dough – use your favorite pizza crust recipe, or this no rise one. Alternatively, grab dough from your local pizzeria or use store-bought dough. Even flatbread topped with these ingredient combos will be delicious.
Option 1 – Lemon Anchovy Pizza
Ingredients: You will need a tin of cured anchovies in olive oil, lemon, sour cream (or creme fraiche), onion, freshly ground pepper and parsley as garnish. For obvious reasons skip the salt.
Mozzarella cheese is not needed here, the sour cream is just perfect against the caramelized lemon slices, mellowed onions and the anchovies, but if you want to add a little bit go for it.
Here is how to make it: Slice the lemons super thin. As thin as possible – use a mandoline slicer if necessary.
TIP: If you are a fan of preserved lemons, they can boost the flavors of this pizza significantly.
Then roll out your pizza dough (thin works better for this recipe), spread sour cream, lay down thinly sliced onions, arrange the lemon circles and scatter whole anchovy fillets (as many as you’d like).
Season with freshly ground pepper.
Bake in a 425 F oven and garnish with finely chopped parsley right before enjoying.
Option 2 – Olives and Capers Anchovy Pizza
Ingredients: Both marinara and fresh mozzarella join the cast of ingredients in this Napoletana inspired version. Supporting acts for the anchovies are capers and olive. Once again, parsley is a great fresh herb to garnish the pizza with, but if you prefer the more traditional basil use it.
How to make it: Use your favorite marinara sauce, homemade if you have a good recipe, and apply a generous amount.
Then place fresh mozzarella pieces, capers, your favorite olives and the anchovies.
Bake in a 425 F oven and enjoy with a bit of grated Parmesan on top.
Pizza Topping Ingredients Compatible with Anchovies
As already indicated above, onions, lemon, capers, olives, fresh parsley or basil, marinara or sour cream all go well with cured anchovies.
Here are a few more ideas.
Tomato sauce – if you are fearful about adding whole cured anchovies on top of your pizza but want to experience their taste – add a couple of fillets to your tomato sauce, blitz them with your hand blender and use the even tastier sauce.
Ricotta cheese – the neutrality of fresh ricotta is the perfect backdrop for the salty, umami anchovies.
Roasted red peppers – their sweetness and unique flavor embrace the contribution of cured anchovies.
Garlic – grate a clove or two and mix it with the anchovies to make a paste. Then spread onto your pizza crust, top with marinara or sour cream and maybe some mozzarella.
Chicken – bland cooked chicken breast will instantly get a boost of flavor from the anchovies – scatter both over your pizza. Alternatively, you can brown ground chicken in a pan along with several anchovy fillets (smash them with a spoon and incorporate them in the ground meat as you stir it while browning).
Pineapple – the unique sweetness of a few pineapple chunks scattered amidst the anchovies boosts the flavor base.
The Anchovies – Craft Beer Connection
The saltiness of the little flavor bombs makes them a perfect partner for beer. From steak Caesar salads, through anchovies and capers compound butter over grilled fish or chicken, to anchovy pizza. Anchovies and beer have a natural affinity for each other.
- Look for crisp, highly carbonated pale lagers such as German pilsners – the stiff, hoppy bite of the Northern variety is my favorite, but other more balanced alternatives pair well too.
- Dark lager such as Munich dunkel or Vienna lager (most Mexican dark lagers are Vienna lagers) have malty, caramely sweetness which plays off of the umami of the anchovies quite well.
- Among the ales look for – saisons and Belgian blonde ales, Belgian wits, American wheat ales, Gose, Berliner Weisse, citrusy IPAs and pale ales and even hoppy reds.
This post contains affiliate links which help support our blog at no cost to you.
My anchovies pizza past
Why do people like anchovies on pizza so much? Or hate them so much?
During my college years a roommate worked a couple of hours a night at a local pizza place for extra cash. On the menu were several pizzas with anchovies as a topping. Whenever someone forgot to specify that they would like to have the anchovies excluded from the toppings some serious problems appeared… They wouldn’t touch the pizza, as if it was so hard to simply remove the anchovies.
Frequently, the pizza place would just remake the pizza to please the customer and the pie with the anchovies on it ended up with the employees… who often didn’t care for it. But my roommate did, and so did I. We had many impromptu late night ‘study’ sessions with a slice of delicious anchovy pizza in one hand and a beer in the other in result. Never appreciated the communal microwave of the dorm more! And now in retrospect – the fact that drinking beer is not frowned upon at barely eighteen in Bulgaria. Good times!